• Maata pitkin -matkajuttuja
  • Project archive 2010-2015
  • Research Blog 2013-2015
Menu

INARI VIRKKALA PROJECT ARCHIVE

Architect focusing on the social impacts of the built environment
  • Maata pitkin -matkajuttuja
  • Project archive 2010-2015
  • Research Blog 2013-2015

2013 - 2015 Social Structure


During 2013-2015 I was working on the "Social Structure" research project. The aim was to define economic models for architects to work on social impact design. The research was conducted trough qualitative interviews with chosen professionals and combined with work periods of 3 months in 4 different practices focusing on social impact design. The blog Social Structure documents these interviews and the learning process throughout 2013-2015. The project is funded with Antti Nurmesniemi-grant from Asko foundation. Preliminary interviews were funded with a grant from the Finnish Association of Architects (SAFA) and Väinö Vähäkallio scholarship from Aalto University.

Swedish and Ecuadorian discussions

April 17, 2014

On Thursday 3.4.2014 I was happy to have two interesting visitors to take to the KKYC site.

Malu Borja in an Ecuadorian architect and one of the founders of Studio Al Borde. From Phnom Penh she continued to Pursat to work with ngo Sustainable Cambodia.

www.albordearq.com

Ingemar Saevfors has done his career as an architect mostly working on public projects in the developing world. Nowadays he is focusing on bamboo and especially working to determine ways for structural calculations for the organic material and thus optimization and cost-efficiency of structures. I am looking forward of the discussion based on his presentation at the Bamboo summit in HCMC in the end of April.

www.saevfors.se

Bamboo composites and ecological treatment methods

April 17, 2014

I traveled to Chiang Mai to learn from the different bamboo projects in the area. One of them was Chalet & Bamboo, which has unfortunately finished it's work on structural bamboo and is now focusing on developing products from specially cut bamboo fibres.

However, on Wednesday 16.4.2014 I had a great talk with Wolf Podlinski from Bamboo Fibres Ltd. to hear of their experiences and challenges in treating bamboo in an ecological way.

www.chalet-bamboo.com

KatieCrepeau.jpg

Katie Crepeau and Design Affects

April 17, 2014

Katie Crepeau, the founder behind the site Design Affects and a current writer for Public Interest Design -blog was interviewed online on 4.2.2014. 

Katie’s interest in public interest design began with a university course led by Matt Miller from Project H at Berkeley. She was working with the projects of Architecture for Humanity in San Francisco Chapter for a while, where they were running for a “community design office”. However, managing the office ambitiously enough was too much to manage on voluntary basis. This initiated the founding of the Design Affects -site, which aims to document ways to work on public interest design on full time basis.

Currently this has led Crepeau to work for a startup focusing on neighborhood interaction in London and write 1-2 posts for PID-blog a week. She also recently became a member of the board of ngo Azuko. When asked to mention a few inspiring practitioners on the field, Crepeau mentioned Katherine Darmstad from Latent Design as well as Jan Gehl and his way of basing design on anthropological research.

www.designaffects.com

Some other interesting initiatives discussed in the call:

Co-Housing

Hanover Developers 

Peter Devlin, architect at PTE who is working on senior cohousing designs in London

UK Cohousing

Cohousing event put on by CPRE

 

London

Social Design Talks (Mapping Social Design)

RSA Student Design Awards

Harriet Harriss & forthcoming book Architecture Live Projects

Giacomo Butte

Giacomo Butte: step outside the architect's traditional role

March 26, 2014

Italian architect Giacomo Butte has been working in Cambodia for 4 years. He first arrived to work with the housing rights ngo Sahmakum Teang Tnaut (STT), whichafter founding his own practice, the collaborative studio with Australian Eva LLoyd.

Using building design as a tool in poverty alleviation, Giacomo emphasized the importance of stepping out of the traditional role of an architect and acquiring skills from other professions as from economists, civil and mechanical engineers.

Giaocomo Butte was interviewed on 27.1.2014 in Phnom Penh.

www.giacomobutte.com
acollaborativestudio.wordpress.com

HCD Emilie.jpg

HCD iLab: Asia's first innovation lab to serve to poor

March 26, 2014

"Design for the other 90%. Apple, IDEO, IKEA, Nokia, Proctor & Gamble... the list goes on. Successful companies in developed economies use human centered design (HCD) as a core business practice. But today, design‐thinking is used almost exclusively to create products and services for the richest 10% of the world.

What if we could apply HCD to problems that are of life‐and‐death importance? There is growing recognition of HCD in the developing world, resulting in the launch of innovations such as solar lights, drinking water systems, and infant incubators designed to meet user needs. With the HCD i‐Lab, we want to fuel this revolution in design. We will bring the best HCD thinking to the developing world, to design for the world’s other 90%.

HCD i ‐ Lab is the first HCD innovation lab of its kind in South East Asia, with a mission to bring the best practices in innovation to serve the poor. We are a non ‐ profit consulting practice within iDE, based in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. In 2009, iDE worked with IDEO to develop an HCD Toolkit for designing pro ‐ poor products and services. Human ‐ centered design, also known as design ‐ thinking, guides our work at the i ‐ Lab. We have worked to design a range of solutions, including the products, services, marketing, and distribution strategies relating to drinking water filters, low cost toilets, and affordable hand washing stations."

Emilie Hitch, an anthropologist working for the HCD i-Lab was interviewed on Sunday 2.2.2014.

www.ide-cambodia.org

Urban Elephant

Peng Li: Urban Elephant on Cantonese urban spaces

March 26, 2014

After learning to know Urban Elephant's David Gregory and LiYan Yang in the Architecture for Humanity's Design Like you Give a Damn conference last fall, I was very happy to get a chance to visit their office in Guangzhou while transiting trough the city.

Peng Li, one of the partners, presented me the current works of the office and we had an interesting discussion on urban design in China and in Guangzhou in specific.

According to Peng Li, social impact design as a term can't be said to exist in China. However, Urban Elephant focuses on public projects and especially in conservation of the historical center. Their biggest project so far is the ongoing revitalization of old canal structures of Guangzhou, which have become very lively urban spaces.

The office was started four years ago with four friends. Conservation is a clear direction for the company, but this kind of work can't feed the office entirely and private customers are needed to support the public projects. All the partners are all in their early 30s. Nowadays in China there are great opportunities also for young architects and offices to handle big projects. The conservation projects came to the office via a professor at the university, very well known for his specialization in historical buildings and environments. Peng Li himself has an international background, he completed his Master's in TU Delft and worked for Foster & Partners for a few years.

Compared to Peking and Shanghai, conservation in Guangzhou is a new phenomenon. However, attitudes are changing fast and just last year the city government started looking at the historical preservation of the old city. This is due to the change in the government: as the rulers of the city want to leave their mark to the city, they are now looking into areas untouched by their predecessors.

Most architects in Guangzhou don't have much consideration on social issues in their designs and there is not much interest in the old city.  The internationally rising interest on good quality urban spaces as for example the High Line in New York has not reached China and Guangzhou yet. When asked about the Chinese preferences of urban spaces Peng Li answered that there are no special preferences, as "the cities are so dense, that any urban open space will become popular. This is different from the west, where people are more aware of the quality of the spaces. In China the density is so high so just an open space is enough."

Guangzhou Canal
UE canal 2.jpg





Social Impact Design: Moving from marginal to majority

March 13, 2014

Encouragingly, on the website of Stanford Social Innovation Review John Cary writes how social impact design has become a major interest for donors and foundations "design has become a consistent topic of discussion across the philanthropic and social sectors."

"Leveraging their collective support, we hope to see a surge in design for a better world, where one day, impactful projects like Rwanda’s breathtaking Butaro Hospital are not the exception, but the norm."

maslow.jpg

Social impact design vs. DWYL vs. real need

January 19, 2014

As a social impact designer one works often for customers who can't pay for the services of the designer. Why then actually, does the designer do the work? To save the world? To get a project built for acting as effective marketing for a starting office?

The motives behind pro bono work are under continuous discussion. It is also a hot topic within the South of North -collaboration of Nordic architects, who have been working on community projects in developing countries.

One explanation that I've come to think of, is that social impact design is actually very selfish business. According to Maslow's hierarchy of needs, It fulfills the designers highest need of self actualization when the designer is "able to use one's professional skills for common good."

But then, does it really matter what the motives are, as long as the end result is a positive one (such as completing a youth center to Cambodia for the use of two ngos).

These are thoughts that I will continue to examine further and especially in relation to the discussions on Do What You Love -work and if the provided development aid really responds to the greatest need.

(Picture of Maslow's hierarchy of needs stolen from www.21stcentech.com)

2014 Social Structure Interviewees_Portola.jpg

Portola Community meeting with designer David Bill presenting Activate McCoppin

January 14, 2014

Architecture for Humanity San Francisco Chapter is working on a project in the Portola district to establish a pocket park. I participated in a community meeting of the neighborhood to come up with ideas of how to activate the space. Designer David Bill was presenting the Activate McCoppin project.

Story of the project in Inhabitat.

A nice video of the project on Lincoln's website.

Screen Shot 2014-01-11 at 11.48.11 PM.png

Architecture for Humanity Chapter Quarterly: Thoughts from a HQ Volunteer

January 12, 2014

"How to work as a social impact designer in an economically sustainable way?

Stanford Social Innovation Review (Ten Nonprofit Funding Models, spring 2009) states the core problem very well: “...running a nonprofit is generally more complicated than running a comparable size for-profit business. When a for-profit business finds a way to create value for a customer, it has generally found its source of revenue; the customer pays for the value.

When a non - profit finds a way to create value for a beneficiary (for example, integrating a prisoner back into society or saving an endangered species), it has not identified its economic engine."

Read the whole column in the latest Architecture for Humanity Chapter Quarterly, edited by Tinna Lykke Madsen and Garrett Jacobs.

Tim Culvahouse.jpg

Tim Culvahouse: Catalytic consulting as a resource for design and architecture

January 9, 2014

Tim Culvahouse is an american architect who works as an independent consultant via his company Culvahouse Consulting. From 2000 to 2012, he edited arcCA (Architecture California), the journal of the American Institute of Architects California Council. arcCA is no longer published in print format, but Culvahouse continues to work with AIACC as Editor-in-Chief.

Culvahouse is a great resource for knowledge and his "connecting people" approach. It was also interesting to hear that this connecting forms part of his consulting work. And apparently very efficiently, as Garret Jacobs, the outreach coordinator of Architecture for Humanity told me, that the first thing he did when moving to San Francisco, was to connect with Culvahouse to hear what is going on in the social impact field in the Bay area.

I met with Culvahouse on Tuesday 7.1.2014 in a local cafe in Berkeley. It was a great discussion touching on on various issues as the development of social impact ideology with Team Ten in the 1950s and the impact of Samuel Mockabee in bringing together the "social architect" and the "design architect". 

We also discussed the change of ecological sustainability moving from the marginal to the fundamentals of architectural profession. According to Culvahouse, a real sign of social impact design turning into a mainstream issue is that the largest architecture practices like HOK and Perkins+Will have included it in their business models, Perkins+Will actually already in 2007.

www.culvahouse.net

photo2 copy.jpg

What Can Urban Planning Learn From Tech?

January 8, 2014

What Urban Planning Can Learn From Tech and Vice Versa?

This was the topic of a discussion organized by SPUR on 7.1.2014. Here are some take-aways from the four presenters', Molly Turner / Airbnb, Alicia Rouault / Code for America, Allison Arieff / SPUR and Egon Terplan / SPUR, talks.

Alicia Rouault from Code for America pointed out how the two disciplines share many similar methods, but just call them with different names:

TECH     /     PLANNING

agile/lean     /     Lighter, quicker, cheaper

intrative/disruptive     /     Tactical Urbanism

MVP     /     pilot

user reserach     /     needs finding

 

Molly Turner, director of public policy for Aibnb, argued that it is a necessity for planners to start benefiting more of the tools that are out there: "This is not an intersection [of disclipines], it is a one way street. The broader urban planning community is already present."

According to Turner, biggest take-aways for planning from tech are:

  • Don't ask limiting questions -  ask instead: How might we?
  • Entertain crazy ideas
  • Prototype and ideate rather than just vision
  • Design the end-to-end user experience
  • Think about scalability and reliability
  • Be entrepreneurial - think bigger!

Turner also presented a list of sites and apps that are changing the way we use and design cities:

  • https://neighborland.com/
  • http://streetmix.net/
  • https://liquidspace.com/
  • http://www.goodeggs.com/welcome
  • http://www.lyft.me/
  • http://creative-currency.org/
  • Boston Citizen's Connect http://www.cityofboston.gov/doit/apps/citizensconnect.asp

And here's a few additions that I¨ve come across:

  • http://www.urbanobservatory.org/
  • https://nextdoor.com/about_us/
  • http://insidemaps.com/
  • http://www.houzz.com/mobileApps
  • http://pricemaps.betterdoctor.com
  • https://findery.com/
  • http://www.locish.com/
  • http://www.yelp.com/
  • http://localdata.com/
  • A good slideshare presentation: Apps for Architecture and Urban Planning, 
    Nicole Henning, Independent UX professional at Apps4Creatives on Nov 15, 2011

Some tools for developers and planners:

  • https://developers.arcgis.com/en/
  • https://geoloqi.com/

And ideas for future ones: http://discoversf.org/

← Newer Posts Older Posts →

Why is Social Impact Design important?


"Trough these small acupuncture acts we could transform the public space into the inclusive builder of community that it should be."
Katherine Darmstadt, Architecture for Humanity Chicago & Latent Design
www.chicagoideas.com

Because it can decrease the environmental impact of our cities:
"The growing emphasis on place making is linked to renewed interest in public transportation, and in walkable communities."
Light, Quick And Cheap: The Big Shift In Urban Planning, Micheline Maynard, Forbes.com 23.10.2013

Because by providing spaces for murals you can decrease maintenance costs of the public sphere:
"They have an active youth arts education program that give kids an alternative to graffiti."
Mural matriarch Susan Cervantes makes it big in art, San Francisco Chronicle 5.11.2014

"As more firms expand that access through pro bono design efforts, the public appreciation of the benefits and necessity of architectural services will also expand."
Architectural Record, October 2008.


Schedule of Social Structure research


Preliminary study period: August-October 2013
08/2013 HPAIR Asia in Dubai as part of European Delegation
08/2013 Tampere Architecture Week with Uusi Kaupunki-collective
09/2013 TAB 2013 Tallinn Architecture Biennale
09/2013 AES Think Big in San Francisco
09/2013 European delegation final seminar in Berlin
10/2013 South of North -seminar in MFA Helsinki

Actual research period: November 2013-November 2014

11/2013 Work in research part begins with Architecture for Humanity HQ in San Francisco

01-03/2014 2nd work in research part with Building Trust International in Cambodia

05-07/2014 3rd work in research part with raumlabor berlin in Germany

10-12/2014 4th work in research part with Architecture et Développement in Siliguri, India

01/2015 Publication of “Social Structure” web-publication

Inari Virkkala | inari.virkkala(a)gmail.com | +358 40 574 1926